Pet Sitter Interview Checklist: Questions to Ask

TL;DR: Quick Answer for Pet Parents:

To find a reliable pet sitter, ask about professional certifications (NAPPS, PSI), pet first aid training, insurance and bonding, and their emergency protocols. Make sure they can follow your pet’s routine, administer medications, and provide appropriate exercise and mental stimulation. Use a structured pet sitter interview checklist to confirm their experience with your pet’s breed and temperament and request references and photo updates.

At Wellness Pet, we know your dog or cat is more than a companion—they are a family member. Choosing someone to care for them while you’re away is an important decision. Whether you’re planning a long trip or need help during a busy week, a professional sitter who prioritizes your pet’s overall wellbeing will give you peace of mind. Below is a clear, Wellness-approved guide and checklist to help you find a professional sitter who truly fits your pet’s needs.

dogs on luggage

Why Choose a Professional Pet Sitter?

It’s tempting to rely on a neighbor or family friend, but a professional pet sitter treats care as their primary responsibility. Certified sitters—often through the National Association of Professional Pet Sitters (NAPPS) or Pet Sitters International (PSI)—bring training and systems that reduce risk and improve your pet’s experience. Professionals are more likely to understand emergency procedures, be insured and bonded, and keep a consistent routine for your pet.

Benefits of hiring a professional pet sitter:

  • Health awareness: Trained sitters can recognize early signs of illness, such as digestive upset or lethargy, and will report concerns promptly.
  • Safety and first aid: Many pros have pet first aid and CPR training, and they follow clear emergency plans.
  • Reliability: A business-minded sitter follows schedules, communicates clearly, and respects house rules.
  • Breed and age expertise: Professional sitters understand differences in energy levels and care needs—what a young Husky requires is different from a senior Pug.

Your Pet Sitter Interview Checklist

Use the questions below to evaluate candidates and ensure they are a good match for your pet’s personality, health, and routine.

Are you certified, insured, and bonded?

Professionalism begins with protection. Insurance and bonding protect you, your home, and the sitter if an accident occurs or something is damaged. This is the baseline requirement for a trustworthy sitter.

How much experience do you have with my pet’s breed and temperament?

Different breeds and ages have unique needs. Ask for experience with pets like yours—high-energy dogs, shy rescues, cats with litter-box sensitivities, or multi-pet households. Avoid a one-size-fits-all approach.

What does a “day in the life” look like during your visits?

A quality visit should be structured and predictable. Expect the sitter to outline the visit routine, which should include:

  • Fresh water and timely feeding: Following your feeding schedule exactly and using the food you provide.
  • Physical and mental activity: Play, walks, or enrichment activities tailored to your pet’s needs.
  • Hygiene and monitoring: Waste cleanup, observation for behavior or appetite changes, and reporting anything unusual.
  • Photo and status updates: Short check-ins with photos to reassure you that your pet is comfortable and safe.

How do you handle medications and medical emergencies?

If your pet requires prescriptions, supplements, or topical care, confirm the sitter’s comfort level and technique. Ask for their written protocol for emergencies, including when they would contact you or your vet and how they would proceed if your pet stops eating, becomes ill, or is injured.

How to Find a Trusted Pet Sitter Near You

pet sitter checklist

Finding the right sitter takes effort, but investing time to screen candidates is worth it for your pet’s comfort and safety. Ask your veterinarian for recommendations, check professional directories, and request referrals from other diligent pet parents.

Where to Look Why It Works
Your veterinarian They know your pet’s health history and can often recommend vetted local professionals.
Professional directories and databases Reputable sites and organizations help filter for certified and experienced sitters.
Your local pet community Ask other pet parents who care deeply about wellbeing for firsthand referrals.

Wellbeing From the Inside Out

Consistent nutrition supports emotional and physical health while you’re away. Maintain your pet’s regular diet to reduce stress-related digestive issues. Choose nutrient-dense recipes with high-quality proteins to keep energy levels steady and mood balanced during transitions.

Pro tip for pet parents: Leave a concise “Pet Care Cheat Sheet” in a visible spot. Include emergency contacts, your vet’s details, your pet’s daily routine, known triggers, favorite treats, and any locations in the home they prefer for resting or scratching.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I find a pet sitter for a dog with anxiety?

Seek a sitter experienced in calm, fear-free handling. Ask for references from owners of anxious pets and inquire about techniques they use to reduce stress, such as low-energy body language, gradual introductions, and short, predictable visits at first.

What is the difference between a pet sitter and a dog walker?

A dog walker primarily provides exercise during the day. A pet sitter offers broader care: feeding, bathroom breaks, medication administration, monitoring, photo updates, and often overnight stays when needed.

Should I leave the TV on for my pet while I’m away?

Background noise can be comforting. Soft music, a low-volume TV, or a white-noise machine can help mask sudden outdoor sounds and give your pet a sense of company in a quiet house.


At Wellness Pet, we focus on the whole-pet approach to wellbeing. Choosing the right sitter and maintaining consistent nutrition ensures your pet thrives—even when you’re not home.

Join the Wellness community to receive guides, nutrition tips, and savings delivered to your inbox.